AI stocks will correct even if the boom is real

Share
AI stocks will correct even if the boom is real

Five European Central Bank economists just argued that history does not care whether today's AI valuations are a bubble or a fair bet — either way, a pullback is the base case.

A Monday ECB Blog post concludes that a correction in current stock-market valuations is likely, even if prices fairly reflect how much AI will remake profits. The authors — Malin Andersson, Johannes Breckenfelder, Stefano Corradin, Kalin Nikolov, and Maria Antonietta Viola — are writing in their own names, not as a Governing Council forecast. That does not make the mechanism any softer. US cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratios sit near their historical peak. Euro-area multiples have risen too, just less. Nvidia's share price is up twenty-fold since 2022. The question they pose is not "is AI real?" It is what happens to the price of a real thing once the whole economy is riding it.

They walk through two stories that end in the same place. The rational one says high multiples can be justified by option value: if the technology works, the upside is hard to bound, so early winners trade rich. Then adoption spreads. Uncertainty stops being a single-sector bet you can diversify away and becomes an economy-wide risk. Investors demand a higher risk premium. Historically, that premium tends to beat even rising profits, and prices fall. The behavioral story is simpler: overconfident buyers push prices past fundamentals, then lose their nerve. Railways, 1920s electricity and radio, and the 1990s internet all followed some version of this arc. The authors are explicit that they cannot time the turn, and that a correction is not a ceiling — if AI is transformative enough, prices can still be much higher later. They are also explicit that you should prepare anyway.

The euro-area reason to care is not a home-grown Nvidia. It is the index fund. Households in the currency bloc now hold about €440 billion of US technology equities, mostly through cheap ETFs and mutual funds, often without seeing the Magnificent Seven concentration underneath — Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Tesla, Meta, Microsoft, and Nvidia. Insurers and pension funds sit on the same stack. A sharp drop can force funds to sell liquid holdings to meet redemptions, then distressed ones, which is how a US tech drawdown becomes a euro-area financial-stability problem. Unlike the dot-com crash, they note, there is markedly less room to cut rates or spend fiscally to cushion the fall. Local markets look less frothy — more old-economy, lower multiples, a digital-investment boom that has still outgrown GDP by more than three times over the past decade — but US and euro-area equities have historically moved together.

This is the price-side twin of the lock-in we already traced on the cash-flow side — The $3T isn't Enron. It's a no-exit clause. The contracts keep the build-out from stopping cleanly. The risk premium is how markets eventually charge for that. Those clocks do not have to ring on the same day.

What to watch: whether euro-area supervisors start treating Magnificent Seven weight in household ETFs as a stability issue, not just a portfolio-choice issue.

If AI really does remake the economy, should a correction still be the base case — or is this just the last cycle's playbook taped onto a new one? Write to us via our contact page.

Get SiliconNoon in your inbox

One email a day with the AI stories that matter — what happened, the numbers, and why it matters. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read more

Temporal nears $500M raise at $12B+ as AI orchestration demand surges

Temporal nears $500M raise at $12B+ as AI orchestration demand surges

Two big moves from the infrastructure side of AI today — one in software, one in hardware — both pointing the same direction: the market is betting heavily on the tools that make AI actually work in production. Temporal is in talks for a fresh funding round that would value the open-source orchestration platform at over $12 billion, with a raise of roughly $500 million. Bloomberg reports the deal is still in progress, but the valuation alone tells the story.

Wispr hits $2B in a Menlo-led round to outgrow dictation

Wispr hits $2B in a Menlo-led round to outgrow dictation

Two signals that AI is moving from clever demos to durable categories: money piling into voice interfaces, and open-source tooling for running agents safely inside companies. Voice AI startup Wispr raised $280 million in a Series B led by Menlo Ventures at a $2 billion valuation, and it's positioning itself as far more than a dictation app. The round brings total funding to $361 million and lands as the company claims 100,000 business customers.

Instabase relaunches as SuperApp to move AI into team work

Instabase relaunches as SuperApp to move AI into team work

Instabase relaunches as SuperApp to move AI into team work Instabase, the unstructured-data company that has raised more than $250 million since 2015, is rebranding as SuperApp and shipping a flagship work platform built around team collaboration with AI models. The new app pairs a Slack-style communication interface with a Google-Docs-like document library and deep access to models from OpenAI, Anthropic and Google — with routing that picks the right model for each task so users don't have to…